Everett Cash Mutual (formerly American Reliable equine) — FBQ Score: 88 | Fast Business Quote
Fast Business Quote 1-833-505-2594 Call an Agent
Compare quotes from top-rated commercial carriers — free, 5 minutes
10+ carriers · No SSN required · No phone call to get pricing
Get My Quotes → 📞 or call 1-833-505-2594
FBQ Carrier Score

Everett Cash Mutual (formerly American Reliable equine)

By Dave Benson · Edited by Justin Marks · Reviewed by Jason Wootton, NPN 7694718 Verify NPN ↗
88
of 100

Based on 1 of 3 pillars.Remaining pillars are in verification — see methodology for details.

The 3 pillars

AM Best Financial Strength 40% weight
88

AM Best raw rating: A. Maps to a 0-100 score per the methodology.

FBQ Price Percentile 30% weight
Pending

Price data is structurally unavailable or pending verification (see methodology).

NAIC Complaint Index 30% weight
Pending

NAIC complaint index not yet pulled — Phase 2 ETL will populate this pillar.

Pending note American Reliable equine book transitioned to Everett Cash Mutual (ECM) per SEOexpert verification 2026-06-07. AM Best A (Excellent) status 'under review (positive)' reflecting ECM transition (Oct 2025). PriceScore NOT RETRIEVABLE VIA AUTOMATION — ECM's farm-ranch rates ARE filed publicly with state DOIs, but SERFF Filing Access (the primary public access portal) explicitly prohibits automated download in its User Agreement. Manual one-off retrieval is permitted; bulk automation is not. Distinct from the other PENDING carriers in the equine pilot where rates are structurally absent (Chubb E&S exempt, Markel inland-marine informational-only, Hartford specialty MGA per-risk). NAIC complaint index pending.

How the FBQ Score is computed

The FBQ Carrier Score is a 0-100 composite weighing three independent data pillars: AM Best Financial Strength (40%) + FBQ Price Percentile (30%) + NAIC Complaint Index (30%). When fewer than 3 pillars are available for a carrier, the score is presented with a "Based on N of 3 pillars" transparency label (never inventing values). Full formula, data sources, and integrity rules are published at /methodology/gbc-score .

Vertical context

Everett Cash Mutual (formerly American Reliable equine) is currently in the FBQ Carrier Score equine pilot — see the Horse Stable Insurance Guide for the full carrier comparison table including sibling equine carriers. Phase-2 + Phase-3 expansion to non-equine verticals (Restaurant, Plumber, Commercial Truck, etc.) is scoped at /methodology/gbc-score.

Frequently asked questions

What is the FBQ Carrier Score?

A 0–100 composite rating for commercial-insurance carriers, blending three independent pillars: AM Best Financial Strength (40%), FBQ Price Percentile (30%), and the NAIC Complaint Index (30%).

How is Everett Cash Mutual (formerly American Reliable equine)'s FBQ Score calculated?

It combines the three weighted pillars above. Everett Cash Mutual (formerly American Reliable equine)'s current score reflects 1 of 3 pillars that are verified; the remaining pillars are in verification (see the methodology).

Where does the FBQ Score data come from?

AM Best financial-strength ratings, FBQ's own price-percentile data from filed rates, and the NAIC complaint index — independent third-party and first-party-disclosed sources, not a single carrier's own book.

Is the FBQ Score an endorsement?

No. It is a transparent, methodology-driven composite for comparison — not a recommendation to buy. The full formula, weights, and data sources are published at /methodology/gbc-score.

FBQ Carrier Score · Published by Fast Business Quote · See methodology for full formula + data sources.

📞 Call Get My Quotes →
An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙